Was this the real Stephen Maturin?

Dr Granville

Portrait of A.B.Granville, by Alexander Craig (c.1840), from Wellcome Library

Some years ago, I belonged to a History of Medicine online discussion group.  Every few months, a query would arrive from a newbie asking what was the disease once known as the marthambles – and the questioner would immediately be outed as a Patrick O’Brian tragic, for it is one of many ailments successfully treated by Stephen Maturin in O’Brian’s highly popular Aubrey/Maturin novels, set in the Royal Navy during the Napoleonic War.  The problem is, marthambles doesn’t exist.  Sometimes a historical novelist is allowed – whisper it quietly – to make things up!

I first encountered Patrick O’Brian’s novels in the late 1970s.  I was working in the Public Record Office in London (now the National Archives) on naval records for my PhD, and the archivist who helped me mentioned O’Brian, who was working on the same records for his latest novel.

Thanks to my conversation with the PRO archivist, I know how well researched those books are.  Real historical characters appear throughout. Robert Farquhar, for instance, who becomes Governor of Mauritius in The Mauritius Command (1977), is certainly a real person: he was the consul at Ambon when John Macarthur visited there in 1802, and I’ve been writing the biography of his cousin, Walter Stevenson Davidson, for too many years.

The Mauritius Command book cover

I’m not a great reader of historical fiction and I haven’t read the whole O’Brian series, but some of my nearest and dearest are fans, and you can pick up a lot through marital osmosis.  So I know the rough outline of the characters and stories.

Stephen Maturin is a half Catalan revolutionary on the run from the authorities when he encounters Captain Jack Aubrey at the British naval base at Port Mahon, on Minorca.  A skilled doctor, he becomes a ship’s surgeon in the Royal Navy.  He performs many surgical miracles, but he is also a scientist, curious about the new discoveries in botany and physics, a linguist and a spy.

Stephen Maturin is no doubt a composite of many medical men who served in the Royal Navy, both during and after the Napoleonic Wars.  Ships surgeons generally had a reputation for drunken incompetence, but many were caring, educated men – though not many fitted as many adventures into their careers as Maturin.

It’s tempting to look for possible models, so may I offer for consideration Exhibit A:

Augustus Bozzi was born in Milan in 1783.  His father’s family was connected to the Bonapartes of Corsica, while his maternal grandmother was English.  He studied medicine at the University of Pavia, and was briefly imprisoned for his republicanism.  After he graduated, he travelled in a theatre troupe, singing and playing the guitar.  In Corfu he met William R. Hamilton, an attaché to Lord Elgin, the British ambassador in Constantinople, and travelled with him in Greece, where together they oversaw the removal of the Elgin marbles from Athens.

Bozzi joined the medical service of the Turkish navy, before transferring to the Royal Navy.  He worked on various ships in the Mediterranean, the West Indies and South America, where he met Simon Bolivar.  In 1811 he carried documents from Bolivar to Sir Robert Peel in London.  During this time he suffered from – and treated himself for – both malaria and yellow fever.  He married an Englishwoman, and adopted his English grandmother’s name, Granville.  Brought up Catholic, he converted to Anglicanism.

Bozzi Granville finally retired from the navy in 1813.  His old friend William Hamilton’s brother was the brother-in-law of Robert Farquhar, the Governor of Mauritius, and Robert’s father, Sir Walter Farquhar, was the Prince Regent’s physician.  With various letters of introduction, these connections gave him entrée into the medical establishment.  On Sir Walter’s advice, he studied at La Maternité in Paris, before setting himself up as a specialist physician in women’s diseases in London.

Irtyersenu autopsy by Granville

Irtyersenu, from the press release of the Royal Society, 1 October 2009

Granville was a man of science.  He was friendly with the chemist John Dalton, and for many years was the secretary to the Royal Institution.  In 1825 he conducted the first autopsy on an Egyptian mummy, Irtyersenu, a woman of about 50.  Like the good gynaecologist he was, he identified her cause of death as an ovarian tumour, though recently Irtyersenu has been re-examined, and she is now thought to have died of tuberculosis.

We will never know how Stephen Maturin’s life might have ended – but Augustus Bozzi Granville lived a long and fruitful life.  He died in 1868, leaving a 2 volume autobiography which is the basis for almost everything we know about his life before he settled in England.  It is a thoroughly entertaining book – and very likely, I suspect, a work of historical fiction as vividly creative as anything that Patrick O’Brian ever wrote.

Further reading:
A. B. Granville, Autobiography of A. B. Granville, ed. P. B. Granville, 2 vols. (1874)

W.B.Howell, ‘Augustus Bozzi Granville – Journeyman Physician’, in Canadian Medical Association Journal, December 19 1931, pp. 719-25.

Helen D. Donoghue, Oona Y.-C. Lee, David E. Minnikin, Gurdyal S. Besra, John H. Taylor, and Mark Spigelman, ‘Tuberculosis in Dr Granville’s mummy: a molecular re-examination of the earliest known Egyptian mummy to be scientifically examined and given a medical diagnosis’, in Proceedings of the Royal Society of Biological Sciences, January 7 2010; 277(1678): 51–56.

Ornella Moscucci, ‘Granville, Augustus Bozzi (1783–1872)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004 [http://www.oxforddnb.com.ezproxy.library.uq.edu.au/view/article/11299, accessed 25 Nov 2011]

The Patrick O’Brian Mapping Project

Advertisements

10 responses to “Was this the real Stephen Maturin?

  1. Excellent article and candidate for the real life model for Stephen Maturin, in the way that Lord Cochrane is a model for Jack Aubrey. As a historical fiction writer I shall put A.B. Granville’s autobiography on my reading list. It is important to be remain steeped in the vernacular of those times.
    http://www.podiobooks.com/title/captain-blackwells-prize

  2. Really interesting perspective! I run a website dedicated to the Aubrey/Maturin series called The Dear Surprise (www.thedearsurprise.com) and I would love to post this entry there, with full attribution of course. I think my readers would find it as fascinating as I did, and maybe use it as a jumping-off point to discuss their own potential candidates. Please let me know if you’d be willing to let me, or if you have any questions.

  3. Hi Ava, I’ve replied on your website, but yes, I’d be very happy for you to link to this post, or copy it with attribution. Cheers, Marion

  4. Pingback: Remembering Dr. James Guthrie, the Real Dr. Stephen Maturin ? | Old Salt Blog – a virtual port of call for all those who love the sea

  5. Pingback: The Feathered Internet | Historians are Past Caring

  6. Pingback: Dead Darlings | Historians are Past Caring

  7. Pingback: What do I do with the Egyptian mummy? | Historians are Past Caring

  8. In The Nutmeg of Consolation not only does Dr. Maturin not cure Marthambles, but he wants to perform an autopsy on the unfortunate patient !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s