A Right Whale in the Wrong Place

Last week a boat strike killed a southern right whale – maybe two – in Moreton Bay. One mangled carcass of a young female finally drifted ashore on Peel Island, where rangers from Parks and Wildlife dragged it above the tide line ‘as high as possible…to allow its natural decomposition to continue.’ Another whale was seen still alive, but with propeller injuries along the length of its body. The calf travelling with the pair has not been seen since Friday, but will surely die as well.

corpse of a right whale

Photograph by Darren Burns of the Quandamooka Yoolooburrabee Aboriginal Corporation

The death of this whale is particularly sad because although the number of humpback whales is rising, and they are now a common sight – even in Sydney Harbour – the southern right whale (Eubalaena australis) continues to struggle and the species remains on the endangered list.

The reason for this lies in the evidence of that floating carcass. Unlike other whales, a dead right whale floats when dead because of its thick blubber, so to whalers, they were the right whales to catch. Not only did they yield more oil, but after harpooning, they could be tethered alongside a vessel, and processed at the whalers’ convenience. So right whales were hunted more than any other baleen whale, and their numbers dropped accordingly.

Whaling off the coast of Australia began virtually from the arrival of the first British colonists. Ships would dump their ‘cargo’ of convicts in Sydney, then head off into the Southern Ocean to hunt for whales. Sperm whales were the most valuable, because of their spermaceti oil, but like all toothed whales they were dangerous too.

Slow moving baleen whales like the humpback and right whale were much easier prey. Humpbacks breed in tropical water off the Queensland coast, but right whales seem to prefer cooler waters. In Australia, that means in calm inlets in South Australia and along the Victorian coast.

So what were these right whales doing in the warmer waters of Moreton Bay?

There are no 19th century records of right whales migrating this far north. Lack of evidence, of course, doesn’t constitute evidence of a lack of whales, but given the colonists’ enthusiasm for harvesting any marine creatures they could profitably kill, including dugong, turtle and other whales, I think someone would have mentioned it. But in the last decade or so, small family groups of right whales have begun to appear off Stradbroke Island and now – disastrously – in Moreton Bay itself.

Mike Noad, an expert on whales at the University of Queensland, has a theory that they are following an old migration route, one that pre-dates the European settlement of southeast Queensland. Early colonial whalers targeted right whales so devastatingly that the southern right whale population had already collapsed by the time the Moreton Bay settlement was founded in 1824. There were no right whales left to follow this minor breeding route northwards.

It seems plausible, though there’s probably no way we will ever know for sure. At present the whales are heading south to the Antarctic, where they will feed on krill during the southern summer. They are slow moving because they can only swim at the speed of their young calves, which were born in the last month or so. For that reason, they need to rest regularly in sheltered bays like Moreton Bay.

But Moreton Bay is no longer a reliable shelter. The bay is a busy place these days. Ferries crisscross the waters, and hydrofoils and water taxis can’t stop quickly. Perhaps they should just slow down.

Boat strikes happen too often, to turtles and dugong as well as whales. What also worries me – as a historian of whaling – is the significance of that name. How many humpbacks and other whale species have been killed by boat strikes in Moreton Bay, but because they were not ‘the right’ whales, their bodies sank to the seabed unrecorded.

See Andrew Darby, ‘Slow down, whales crossing’, Sydney Morning Herald, 2 July 2014.

5 responses to “A Right Whale in the Wrong Place

  1. Thanks Marion. Interesting blog, but very sad.

  2. Hi Marion, I’m interested in this information about the Right whale – is that true that that is the reason the whale is called the right whale because they float and have more blubber? I’m going to write an article for Blank magazine (I’m the environment section editor) about the recent spate of interference of migratory routes of whales, I’m interested in quoting you with full attribution if you don’t mind. i have done a few stories about whales if you would like to see and i am interested in making people aware that other whales than humpbacks exist. (http://blankgc.com.au/author/mic-smith/) I also saw that sperm whales use the bay – do you know anything about this?

    • Hi Mic – you’re very welcome to use my post with attribution.

      I don’t know anything about sperm whales entering the bay. It seems unlikely to me, as they are deep water animals and the bay wouldn’t offer them anything in the way of food – they dive very deep and eat giant squid from the depths.

  3. Hi, I cited this article to Wikipedia “Moreton Bay” and I wonder if you mind.
    By the way, Sperm whales “DO” occur in shallow waters. Larger males occasaionally come into very shallow bay to take rests for short periods, and some particular groups prefer to visit narrow straits or bays to cavort as well. If there are deep sea canyons approaching the coast (such as off Kaikoura and Fiordland in NZ), they appear very close to the shore as well.

    For Queensland coast, however, I’m not so sure about their habitat preference. They must have been reduced severely than their original population size, and large portion of natural histories of Australian Sperm whales are unclear. For instance, they once have been regular migrants to the coast of Albany where we see them rather rarely these days.

    Any species of whales are known to aviod the dangerous areas where busy traffic, noises, fishing nets, and off course huntings are taken place. Because of these, even right whales are known to turn into ‘offshorers’.

  4. Pingback: The correct whale | Blank Gold Coast

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s